Methodology · Decision Rule v1

How every score is built, step by step.

The MOI turns 12 public data points into one score from 0 to 100 for each neighborhood, then into one recommended type of action. The full rule is on this page, so a researcher, an agency analyst or a resident with a calculator can check any score by hand.

Rule locked April 11, 2026 · Developed by Maillard Howell · New York City

12public indicators
4dimensions, 25% each
3urgency tiers
12action classes

Read this first. Phase 1 scores are research-informed estimates. They come from published public data and peer-reviewed research, and they show how the framework works. They have not yet been confirmed against agency data. That check happens in Phase 2, described in section 04.

01 · The rule

Four steps from raw data to a decision.

Each step uses a fixed formula. The same inputs always give the same result.

Step 1

Score each indicator

Every indicator has a floor (scores 0) and a ceiling (scores 100), set from public benchmarks. A neighborhood's value is placed on that range.

(observed − floor) ÷ (ceiling − floor) × 100Disease rates run the other way: (ceiling − observed) ÷ (ceiling − floor) × 100. Results are capped at 0 and 100.
Step 2

Score each dimension

Each dimension has 3 indicators. Its score is their plain average, rounded to a whole number.

D = (i1 + i2 + i3) ÷ 3Rounded half up: 44.5 becomes 45.
Step 3

Score the neighborhood

The MOI score is the plain average of the 4 dimensions. Each one counts for 25%.

MOI = (D1 + D2 + D3 + D4) ÷ 4Rounded half up. Higher means better conditions.
Step 4

Set tier and constraint

The score sets urgency. The weakest dimension sets the type of fix. Together they pick 1 of 12 action classes.

Tier 1 < 45 · Tier 2 45 to 65 · Tier 3 > 65Constraint: Burden if D4 ≤ 30. Otherwise the lowest of D1, D2, D3.

02 · Worked example

Two neighborhoods, start to finish.

The same rule gives two very different answers. A neighborhood like Brownsville has the lowest score in Phase 1. Washington Heights has the highest.

Dimension scores
D1Supply
11
D2Delivery
14
D3Coverage
21
D4Burden
24
Out of 100. Adult obesity in Brownsville is 41%, worse than the benchmark's worst value, so that indicator scores 0.
→
MOI score
(11 + 14 + 21 + 24) ÷ 4
= 70 ÷ 4 = 17.5
rounded half up
18 / 100
Tier 1 · under 45
→
Decision
D4 = 24, which is 30 or below
→ Burden override applies
Health-first intervention

Chronic disease rates are high enough to limit how active people can be. Clinical care comes first: cardiometabolic screening, diabetes prevention and metabolic health programs with DOHMH and NYC Health + Hospitals. Physical activity programs follow.

Action class: Tier 1 · Burden
Timeline: 6 to 18 months, in phases

Same 4 steps, same thresholds. One neighborhood needs clinical care first. The other needs more programs in buildings it already has.

03 · Indicators

12 indicators, all from public data.

Three indicators per dimension. Each one is something a city agency already counts or surveys.

IndicatorDirectionSource
D1 · Supply · Can people get to a place to be active?
Parkland acres per 1,000 residentshigher is betterNYC Parks Open Data · NY4P Open Space Index
Recreation centers within 0.5 miles, open and operatinghigher is betterNYC Parks Open Data · NYC Parks Capital Tracker
Schoolyard open space open to the communityhigher is betterDOE Schools · NYC Parks
D2 · Delivery · Is anything running in those places?
Free program hours per 1,000 residents per weekhigher is betterNYC Parks Recreation Programs · DYCD After School
DYCD after-school physical activity programs activehigher is betterDYCD After School
Senior center physical activity hours per weekhigher is betterDFTA Quarterly Reporting
D3 · Coverage · Are people taking part?
Adults meeting weekly physical activity guidelines (%)higher is betterDOHMH Community Health Survey
Youth enrolled in after-school physical activity programs (%)higher is betterDYCD After School
Seniors enrolled in DFTA mobility and wellness programs (%)higher is betterDFTA Quarterly Reporting
D4 · Burden · What is the health cost?
Adult diabetes (%)lower is betterDOHMH Community Health Profiles 2021 · EpiQuery
Adult obesity (%)lower is betterDOHMH Community Health Survey · EpiQuery
Adult hypertension (%)lower is betterDOHMH Community Health Profiles 2021

The floor and ceiling for each indicator are available on request (see section 04). Phase 2 may add youth fitness data such as DOE FitnessGram. The model stays at 4 dimensions.

04 · Confidence and access

How confident each score is, and what you can request.

Phase 2 rebuilds each dimension from finer census tract data and checks the results against these Phase 1 estimates. Some dimensions are easier to measure than others, so each one carries a confidence rating. Every change is logged here with a date.

D1 Supply

High confidence

Park access and facility locations are well documented in public data.

D2 Delivery

Low confidence

No public dataset counts free programs cleanly. It is the weakest of the 4, and the scores should be read with that in mind.

D3 Coverage

Medium confidence

Survey and visit data exist, but they are thinner in lower-income neighborhoods.

D4 Burden

High confidence

Chronic disease rates are published for every census tract in the city.

Public

On this page

  • The decision rule and every formula
  • The 4 dimensions and 12 indicators, with sources
  • Two worked examples
  • Data confidence for each dimension

All 10 Phase 1 scores are in the Neighborhood Dashboard.

On request

For researchers and partners

  • Technical appendixBenchmarks, weighting rationale, rounding and tie-break rules, full Phase 1 audit
  • Scoring engine workbookEvery formula, cell by cell
  • Validation protocolShared under a short NDA
Request the files

MNHowell00@gmail.com

CitationHowell, M. (2026). Movement Opportunity Index: Methodology, Decision Rule v1.
LicenseThis methodology text is shared under CC BY-NC 4.0. Reuse with credit, non-commercial.
NameMovement Opportunity Index is the subject of a USPTO trademark filing (Class 042, March 2026).